I used to believe there were certain things a wife would always recognize.
Her husband's footsteps.
The way he cleared his throat.
The sound of his voice when he was trying to hide something.
After forty-seven years together, I thought I knew every one of those things about Lamar.
I was wrong about the most important part.
I hadn't known the man himself.
And I discovered that while standing in a restaurant in Florida, looking at a husband I had buried two years earlier.
He was sitting beside my best friend.
Her name was Rhoda.
His name was Lamar Ashby.
Mine was Roberta.
And until that afternoon, I had believed I was a widow.
Neither of them spoke when I approached their table.
I could see that they recognized me.
That was almost worse than the kissing.
They weren't confused.
They weren't wondering whether I had mistaken them for someone else.
They knew exactly who I was.
Lamar's face went pale.
Rhoda pulled back in her chair.
I stood there holding my purse, waiting for one of them to say something.
A waitress arrived before either one managed it.
She carried a pitcher of tea and stopped beside Lamar's chair.
“Would you like another refill?”
Then she noticed me.
Her eyes moved between the three of us.
I could almost feel her trying to understand what sort of trouble she had walked into.
I gave her a small smile.
“Water would be fine. I may be here a while.”
She reached for a clean glass.
Then I added something I never imagined I would say in my life.
“I've just found out my husband isn't dead.”
The waitress stopped moving.
Lamar lowered his head.
Rhoda made a small sound behind her hand.
I couldn't tell whether she was about to cry or be sick.
The waitress looked toward Lamar again.
I almost felt sorry for her.
She had probably come to work expecting ordinary customers and ordinary complaints.
Instead, she had found herself standing beside a woman whose entire marriage had just changed meaning.
“I'll bring your water,” she said quietly.
She walked away.
I pulled out the empty chair across from Lamar and sat down.
A plate of food rested in front of him.
Crab cakes.
I remembered buying crab cakes once for his birthday because he had talked about them for weeks.
He had complained that they were too expensive.
Now he was eating them in Florida with Rhoda.
I noticed that before I noticed the color of his shirt.
That was strange.
Sometimes the smallest things stay clear when everything else feels impossible.
Behind him, I could see the water beneath the restaurant dock.
The sunlight moved across it.
Boats rocked against their ropes.
People continued eating at other tables.
I wanted to ask them how they could possibly carry on.
Didn't they understand what had happened?
A dead man had returned.
At least, he had returned to me.
He had apparently been living an ordinary life for quite some time.
Lamar finally lifted his eyes.
“How did you get here?”
I stared at him.
That was what he wanted to know.
Not whether I had been lonely.
Not whether I had managed to pay the bills.
Not whether I had survived the two years since the sheriff came to my door.
He wanted to know how I had found him.
“I came with Ione,” I said. “We were getting lunch.”
He rubbed his fingers against his forehead.
“Roberta, we shouldn't do this in front of everybody.”
I looked around the restaurant.
Nobody had raised a voice.
Nobody had overturned a chair.
The only person behaving strangely was the man who had arranged for his wife to mourn him.
“Where would be better?”
He didn't answer.
“Maybe back home,” I continued. “There's a cemetery where we could have some privacy.”
His mouth tightened.
I leaned forward.
“You know the one. I bought a casket for you there.”
Rhoda began crying.
I turned toward her.
For years, she had been the woman I called when something went wrong.
When I worried about Lamar, I called Rhoda.
When the bank letters frightened me, I called Rhoda.
When I couldn't bear another Sunday alone, I sometimes asked her to sit with me.
I had trusted her.
That was the part I kept struggling to understand.
Lamar had betrayed me as my husband.
Rhoda had betrayed me as the person who knew how badly his supposed death had hurt.
“Roberta,” she whispered, “I'm sorry.”
I looked at her.
“For which part?”
She pressed her napkin against her face.
I watched her hands.
They were trembling.
I knew those hands.
I had watched them pour coffee in my kitchen.
I had held them when her husband Clifton died.
I had seen her fold them in church.
And now those same hands were wrapped around a napkin because I had interrupted her lunch with my husband.
“I never wanted you hurt,” she said.
I almost asked whether she understood how foolish that sounded.
Instead, I asked something simpler.
“How long?”
She looked at Lamar.
He gave her a quick look.
It wasn't much.
Just a slight movement of his eyes.
But I recognized it.
They were checking with each other.
I had seen married couples do that at the hospital when they didn't want to tell a nurse the truth.
One person would wait for the other.
The other would decide what could safely be admitted.
I had worked as a nurse for forty-one years.
I knew that look.
“How long have you been seeing each other?” I asked.
Rhoda wiped her cheeks.
“It's been a while.”
“How long, Rhoda?”
She swallowed.
“Close to three years.”
I sat very still.
Three years.
Lamar had only been missing for two.
I didn't need a calculator to understand what that meant.
For about a year before he disappeared, he had been coming home to me while carrying on with my best friend.
He had been sitting across from me at breakfast.
He had been asking whether we needed groceries.
He had been telling me what needed repairing at the bait shop.
And sometime during those ordinary days, he had been finding ways to see Rhoda.
I remembered her coming into my kitchen after Clifton died.
She would sit at the table while I made coffee.
Sometimes she cried.
Sometimes she talked about how quiet her house had become.
I had listened.
I had comforted her.
I had told her that grief took time.
Now I wondered how much of her sadness had been real.
I didn't want to believe all of it had been false.
Clifton deserved better than that.
He had been a decent man.
He worked hard and spoke gently.
Every summer, he brought us tomatoes from his garden.
He would leave them in a paper bag on the counter and tell me to use them before Lamar ate them all.
I remembered one anniversary dinner when Clifton lifted his glass and joked that he would take my side if Lamar ever became difficult.
We had laughed.
All four of us.
Looking back, I remembered something else about that evening.
Rhoda had spent a surprising amount of time leaning toward Lamar.
They had spoken quietly while Clifton sat beside her.
I hadn't been suspicious.
Why would I have been?
We were friends.
We had shared meals, birthdays, church services, and funerals.
I believed those things meant we were safe with one another.
I turned back toward Rhoda.
“Did Clifton find out?”
She shook her head.
“I don't think so.”
That wasn't quite the answer I wanted.
“Did he know about you and Lamar?”
“No.”
She said it quickly.
Then she said it again.
“He didn't know, Roberta.”
I wanted to accept that.
Clifton had already died once.
I didn't want to imagine him spending his final days knowing his wife was betraying him.
But I had just learned how easily a person could sit across from someone and conceal an entire second life.
I didn't know what to believe anymore.
I turned toward Lamar.
“Tell me about the lake.”
He frowned.
“What about it?”
“The day they said you drowned.”
He shifted in his chair.
I could see he was uncomfortable.
Good.
For two years, I had been uncomfortable in ways he couldn't possibly understand.
“Where were you?” I asked.
He looked toward the dock.
“I wasn't actually out in the water.”
“I gathered that.”
His fingers tightened around the edge of the table.
“The business had problems.”
I waited.
He looked at me as though I should understand immediately.
“It was getting worse. I didn't know how to fix it.”
“The bait shop?”
He nodded.
I thought about all the evenings when I had asked him whether business was good.
He had usually said it was fine.
Sometimes slow.
Sometimes better than expected.
Nothing that required me to worry.
He had told me to enjoy retirement when the time came.
We had worked too hard to spend our remaining years frightened about money.
That was what he said.
Now he was telling me the business had been in serious trouble.
“You told me we were all right.”
“I was trying to handle it.”
“By disappearing?”
He looked away.
I remembered the day he asked me to sign paperwork for the bank.
He had said it was connected to insurance.
There had been forms.
Places marked for my signature.
He told me it was routine.
I had signed because he was my husband.
Because we had been married so long.
Because I had never imagined I needed to examine every word before trusting him.
Now I felt ashamed of how easily I had believed him.
Lamar leaned forward.
“I didn't think things would end up the way they did for you.”
That sentence stopped me.
I looked at him for a long moment.
Then I began telling him what those two years had actually looked like.
I told him about the funeral.
About buying a casket nobody would ever open.
About standing at the cemetery while people bowed their heads and prayed for his soul.
I told him about selling the bait shop.
The truck.
The things I had believed we could no longer afford.
I told him about the ninety thousand dollars in debt I had paid because I believed those obligations were ours.
I had used savings we spent years building.
Money I had earned working long shifts at the hospital.
Money I thought would help us grow old without worrying about whether the electricity would stay on.
I told him how frightened I had become of spending anything unnecessary.
Sometimes I put groceries back on the shelf.
Sometimes I sat at the kitchen table adding the same numbers again and again.
I had been afraid of running out.
All while he was alive somewhere else.
Then I told him about the cemetery.
Every Sunday for the first six months, I had gone to his grave.
Sometimes I carried flowers.
Sometimes I didn't have the energy.
I would sit beside the stone and talk.
About the weather.
About people from church.
About little things happening in the neighborhood.
When our old dog died, I told Lamar about that too.
I had cried so hard that day I could barely get the words out.
I thought he was gone.
I thought the grave was the only place where I could still speak to him.
But he hadn't heard any of it.
He had been living in Florida.
I looked across the table.
“Do you understand what that did to me?”
His eyes had changed.
For a moment, he looked like the man I remembered.
Tired.
Ashamed.
Unable to find a comfortable place for his hands.
He began saying my name.
I stopped him.
“Don't speak to me the way you used to.”
He closed his mouth.
“You don't get to comfort me through something you caused.”
The waitress returned with my water.
She placed it on the table and moved away without asking another question.
I looked down at the glass.
There was a thin line of moisture running down the outside.
I watched it reach the table.
Then Rhoda reached toward me.
“Please try to understand,” she said. “He was frightened.”
I moved my hand away from hers.
“Were you frightened too?”
She lowered her head.
“He thought he could explain later.”
“Later than two years?”
She had no answer.
I looked at her wrist.
And that was when I noticed the bracelet.
It was narrow and gold, with a little blue stone that caught the sunlight.
I recognized it immediately.
Lamar had given me that bracelet for our fortieth wedding anniversary.
He said he bought it from a jewelry store in Tallahassee.
I had worn it so often the clasp sometimes caught on my sleeve.
After his funeral, I placed it in a small velvet box.
I couldn't stand seeing it.
Now it was on Rhoda.
I pointed toward her wrist.
“Where did that come from?”
She covered it.
Too late.
Lamar shut his eyes.
I kept looking at Rhoda.
“That was my anniversary present.”
She stared at the table.
“Lamar gave it to me.”
There were many things I might have said.
I could have asked how he got it.
I could have asked whether she knew it had belonged to me.
I could have demanded they explain why even that small piece of my marriage had ended up between them.
But I was tired.
Tired in a way that seemed to reach every part of my body.
“Please remove it,” I said.
Rhoda looked up.
She seemed surprised that I wasn't shouting.
I repeated myself.
She unfastened the clasp.
Her fingers fumbled once.
Then she placed the bracelet between our plates.
I looked at it.
For years, I had thought that little blue stone represented forty years of love.
Now it was just a bracelet.
I didn't pick it up.
“Keep it.”
Rhoda looked as though she wanted to protest.
I stood before she could.
Lamar reached toward my arm.
I stepped away.
“No.”
He pulled back.
“We have to work this out.”
I looked at him.
“You're right about one thing. There is more to discuss.”
I took out my phone.
I had photographed him at the restaurant.
His face.
Rhoda beside him.
Enough to prove the husband everybody thought had drowned was sitting in Florida eating lunch.
I told him I had the photographs.
I told him I had kept some of the financial documents from the years after his disappearance.
I didn't know whether those papers would mean anything to an investigator.
I wasn't even certain I had kept the right ones.
But I knew Lamar.
Or at least I thought I still knew something about him.
And when I mentioned examining the money, his face changed.
His eyes sharpened.
He sat up straighter.
“What documents?”
I held his gaze.
“The ones from home.”
He looked toward Rhoda.
Her face went pale again.
Something passed between them.
It frightened me more than the crying had.
Lamar lowered his voice.
“Roberta, there are things involved that you don't understand.”
I wanted to laugh.
He had made me a widow.
He had spent two years hiding with my closest friend.
And he was still talking as though I was the confused one.
“Then you can explain them.”
He shook his head.
“Not in this restaurant.”
I looked toward the water one last time.
“All right. Tomorrow morning.”
His eyes widened slightly.
“You want to meet tomorrow?”
“Yes.”
I put my phone away.
“Unless you're thinking of disappearing again.”
He looked down.
I picked up my purse.
Then I stopped.
There was one question I had wanted to ask from the moment I saw him.
Not about the money.
Not about Rhoda.
Not even about the funeral.
I looked at him.
“Was any of our marriage real to you?”
His face tightened.
For several seconds, he couldn't answer.
Then he said he had loved me.
I believed that he believed it.
Perhaps that was the saddest part.
He thought love could exist beside everything he had done.
I nodded.
Then I left the table.
I didn't look back at the bracelet.
I didn't look back at Rhoda.
I had walked into that restaurant believing I was going to eat lunch.
I walked out knowing that the husband I had mourned had chosen to leave me alive with all the consequences of his decisions.
And before the afternoon was over, I would learn that his disappearance had involved much more than another woman.
Click here to continue reading: PART 2: The Message I Received Outside the Restaurant Showed Me That My Husband Had Taken Money on the Day I Learned He Was Dead
I Sat Across From the Husband I Had Buried Two Years Earlier and Waited for Him to Explain Why He Was Alive
Part 1 of 25
